Episode 34

Date: September 8, 2025

Episode 34 Summary:

• Bud notes
• Susan Monarez of the CDC, fired: https://apnews.com/article/cdc-director-susan-monarez-50dfbec849b53b4593755d2e6e616687
• After the podcast was recorded, a panel voted to continue allowing the covid vaccine prescription-free: https://www.cbsnews.com/atlanta/live-updates/cdc-vaccine-advisory-panel-covid-19-hepatitis-b-vaccines/
• The government can fund without the profit motive, because the government can originate money. See our podcasts on modern monetary theory for an explanation. https://mondayswithmike.ddns.net/episode22.html https://mondayswithmike.ddns.net/episode23.html
• Elections have consequences, and now the Trump administration controls the CDC. Depending on the degree of difficulty created by this circumstance, states could move into a position to play a greater role in healthcare recommendations. But it's going to take more than what's been undertaken thus far-- it will take years of earnest effort to build up legitimacy.
• AI summary
• In this episode of the podcast titled "Vaccine Battle Lines," hosts Bud and Mike delve into the turbulence surrounding the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) in the United States. The conversation centers around the significant upheaval within these agencies, particularly the mass resignation and replacement of the entire vaccine recommendation panel. Mike highlights the gravity of the situation, underlining how unprecedented it is for such a panel to be dismissed en mass move that has raised questions about the scientific credibility and expertise of the new appointees. This shake-up is linked to broader political maneuvering, with Robert F. Kennedy Jr. (RK Jr.), a controversial figure known for his vaccine skepticism, playing a significant role in the ongoing debates and adding layers of complexity and mistrust to the discourse.
• The discussion also addresses the implications of a perceived lack of consensus among experts and the potential influence of bias on official health policy. Mike and Bud question the legitimacy and independence of these new appointments. There is a particular concern regarding the capacity of the new panel to uphold the rigorous standards necessary for public health decisions. Moreover, the podcast underscores the symbolic chaos represented by the abrupt firing of Susan Menez, the former CDC director, only 29 days into her tenure, hinting at a disconnect between political motives and public health needs.
• A critical point of contention during the show is RK Jr.'s apparent skepticism of established scientific data, particularly concerning COVID-19 statistics and vaccine recommendations. This skepticism is reshaping the way health policies are being framed and altering public access to necessary vaccines, given that insurance coverage is often contingent upon government recommendations. Mike voices concerns about the political motivations driving these changes, emphasizing the delicate balance needed between ensuring public health and political maneuvering.
• In reaction to these federal-level issues, the West Coast states (Washington, Oregon, and California) are reportedly organizing a regional alliance to uphold what they perceive as necessary health standards despite federal actions. This movement emerges as a potential counter to the perceived dismantling of scientific authority at the federal level, though Mike and Bud are skeptical about its potential effectiveness on a national scale.
• The conversation closes on a philosophical note, pondering the fundamental nature of truth and expertise in public health policy as expressed by RK Jr. This skepticism could lead to detrimental effects on public health measures, notably vaccines, and affects broader issues such as research funding for diseases that lack commercial viability. The hosts express concern that such fundamental disagreements on health policy could lead to a fragmentation of consensus, affecting not only health outcomes but also educational and institutional practices across the country.

Back to Homepage